Most Common Misconceptions String Players Have About Posture & Muscle Strain in Shoulders, Back & Neck

Screenshot 2017-05-21 21.54.57by Rozanna Weinberger

It amazes me when speaking to students that say they have excess tension in their playing that causes pain but feel at the mercy of the tension because they don’t even know when it begins. Its true once we’re in the state of compromised physical patterns, the challenge is to relieve the pain and self adjust. Being able to do so, even in a performance situation is really the ideal. But I also believe players are less helpless than they believe. Discovering that the inefficient patterns in playing a violin or viola occur in preparation to play and contribute to a host of new problems once we start to play.

The truth is most inefficient patterns occur as we prepare to play. The way we organize ourselves to hold the instrument and prepare the bow arm to produce a sound are hardwired for the very first impulse to raise our arms in preparation.

Screenshot 2017-06-01 23.08.15

The natural unforced weight of head is a simple and effective way to secure instrument against the shoulder & clavicle, so long as there is no tension in neck, rather the passive weight. Head should be facing forward with very slight tilting to the left when playing.

But its even more interesting that some of the most crucial ‘practicing’ and mindful awareness needs to happen as we’re ‘positioning’ ourselves to play – the moment when we hyperextend the shoulders to engage our bow arm or thrust the left shoulder forward in an attempt somehow hold the instrument.

Its also in that split second when we thrust the head forward in the mistaken belief it will enable us to secure the instrument against our shoulder, when in fact the weight of the head can easily be accessed without jutting the neck and chin forward. And the more one hyper extends the limbs to play, the more ones technique will be based on movements of the limbs rather than accessing the entire torso..Indeed just getting ready to play is when some of the key problems happen and worst of all, once we’ve contorted our bodies its very difficult to change after we start to play. Thats why its valuable to be hyper vigiliget about everyone movement we make from resting position to picking up our instruments because it forms the basis of most of our technique.

The Unfailing Function of the Abdominal Muscles

In contemporary society people try to work out in the gym in hopes of getting in good physical shape.  When it comes to improving our abdominals people often do sit ups to strengthen that muscle group. Yet considering their function and how the abdominals can improve our overall ability to carry ourselves, it is an important consideration and perhaps not discussed enough except when doing Pilates, Gyrotonics, Yoga or other forms of exercise that address lengthen the limbs and functionality.. For great posture, we don’t just need strong abdominals, we need them to lengthen and support our upper bodies effectively. If they don’t do this, other problems will occur as a result of compensation, such as raising and tensing the shoulder in the mistaken belief we holdup our upper bodies by elevating our shoulders.  Other problems will include slouching.

And when it comes to string playing the use of the abdominal muscles is almost never addressed. For sure the abdominal muscles are never discussed in technique books. And yet the abdominal muscles are so crucial in supporting our torso and lengthening out the space between the vertebrae. This support is at the heart of being able counter the effects of gravity when supporting our instruments and at the heart of being able to effectively balance a violin or viola.

Screenshot 2017-05-27 22.32.09

When we press down into the ground with our hands we can access the feelings of lifting and support the abdominal muscles contribute in supporting posture

Awareness of the Spine is Crucial

Stretching is another misconception. When it comes to supporting our upper body effectively its not just a matter of standing taller, but noticing and articulating the natural curvature and straightening of the spine. We need to cultivate the ability to access the sensations of our spine, to the extent that we can feel where we are slumping, where we are compressing the vertebrae and as well as the ability to elongate the spine without leaning backwards or forwards in excess. The curious student will discover many ways to develop kinesthetic awareness as well as ways to make the beneficial connection when it comes to playing with ease.

But when these supporting muscles are able to support the torso sufficiently, the shoulder and its accompanying bones, muscles & ligaments will do what gravity encourages and rest atop the rib cage. They may move and occasionally be elevated but the are a cog in the wheel and not the fulcrum. Screenshot 2017-05-29 20.18.31

Some find it difficult to isolate the movements of the rib cage vs. the shoulders and arms. A simple motion study of curling and lengthening of our spine with hands clasped behind the head, can be useful in isolating those muscles needed. 


4 thoughts on “Most Common Misconceptions String Players Have About Posture & Muscle Strain in Shoulders, Back & Neck

  1. A very sensible and useful article. Rozanna’s tips help us to understand that we don’t “master the violin”. We master, as far as we can, our bodies. It is our whole organism with its muscles bones, senses, nerves, the wrists, the nails even, that we have to adapt into playing any instrument or addressing any task at all. When someone like Rozanna bothers to leave her other, no doubt important tasks and devotes some time for us, we ought to be thankful.

    Sent from Mail for Windows 10

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I am so glad to have stumbled upon your videos and website. I am an adult beginner, having played as a youth many years ago, but it’s like starting over for me. I really have to be aware of my body mechanics when playing, due to some trigger point issues I’ve had in the past. I do yoga and sleep in recommended positions in order to curb any issues with regard to my neck, so I have to be able to hold the violin properly so as to avoid any pain or tension. I tried shoulder rests but have never liked them nor felt comfortable with them. I am grateful for these articles and tips. I will be incorporating them into my learning. Thanks Rozanna!


    • Dear Kara,
      I’m delighted to hear this blog and videos have been helpful to you. There are many misconceptions about playing I hope to clear up as well as shining some light on new possibilities. Thank you! Rozanna


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s